Well, no you're not wrong. The whiteish fungus concepts are living flora too.
blackbird wrote:The only livings organisms could be some plants. Perhaps we could use some of the ashlands plants, like trama shrubs, firefern, scathecraw, ash grass.
Since you seemed to disagree with my idea of the white ash fungus earlier, I figured this remark was related to that. (i.e. that you meant to say those plants should be the only living organisms and not the fungus.)
So with my reply...
Without anything else to make the place look interesting it would still be just ashlands with water. Not the way to do it imo. A player wouldn't even recognize it as something new.
... I meant that if there is nothing besides dead trees and some standard ashland plants, this area will not in fact be unique at all.
I think this part of the discussion can stop now. I only keep repeating my opinion, and I'm going to hold my ground regarding the look of the ash swamp.
I think it's a little curious (and annoying) that real discussion only starts after I move on to make the claim. I gave people no less than 6 days to comment and discuss my suggestions for the ash swamp object claim, before I went ahead and made it. No one seemed to have any firm objections. I think that if there actually were any, they would (should) have been made clear in those six days.